Review Policies

Review Policies Banner


(If you are looking for our film review policy, please click here.)


Our Book Review Policy

Current  BOOK REVIEW Status:

Horror – Open, limited basis. Hard copy preferred.

Sci-Fi – Open, limited basis. Hard copy preferred.

Kids books – Open to both printed and electronic submissions.

Sci-Fi & Scary accepts books self-, small-, and large-press published works for review consideration.

We are willing to accommodate release day reviews, but we must have been given the book at least 2 months in advance, and you must specify in your review submission that you are wanting a release day review.

Books may be reviewed any time within a 2-3 month period after they’re given to us for review. In some cases, it may be a shorter or longer than specified time frame.

We get a ton of requests, and try to at least respond to each of them, but our emails do tend to turn into black holes at times. Bear with us.

We accept books from the following categories:

  • Science Fiction (Adult, YA)
  • Horror (Adult, YA)
  • Kids Science Fiction (12 and under)
  • Kids Horror (12 and under)

We accept regular book as well as graphic novels.

Disclaimer: We’ve wavered back and forth on including this in my review policy, but given the sheer amount of Christian-themed thrillers we’ve been getting review requests for, we’re just going to state it plainly:

We are not the correct site to submit religious-themed works to. If your book has heavy dose of faith/religion/god-like characters come back to earth – Don’t care if it’s Catholic, Christian, Muslim or whatever…your best bet is just to find another reviewer, as we cannot guarantee unbiased reviews.

We will post reviews on:

  • Goodreads
  • Barnes and Noble (if applicable)
  • Amazon (if applicable)
  • Audible (if applicable)
  • Netgalley (if applicable)
  • Edelweiss (if applicable)
  • This blog

Our review style is honest and casual. There may be puns or snark included.

We are NOT the site to approach for a review if you are expecting an easy 5 star review. We rarely rate something 5 stars.




Folks, we’ve recently had trouble with an author who decided to take an honest review as a personal attack, and proceeded to call the reviewer an internet troll, insist that he was being bashed personally, and so on and so forth. He also said that he “did not ask for a Goodreads or Amazon review”, even though it clearly states in our review policy that we post to applicable sites. So… here’s the deal.

This will not be tolerated. This will absolutely NOT BE TOLERATED. Our reviews are honestly given, without bias, and we try our best to give constructive criticism. Sometimes these reviews are negative. We do not ‘have it out’ for you. We aren’t trying to crush the little man. We try our best to promote independent authors, but if we do not like your book, we are not going to lie and say that we did. We aren’t going to give a false rating to appease your ego or help your sales.

If you submit to this site, you are saying that you promise you will be an adult if you receive a negative review. You WILL not attempt to harass or coerce the reviewer about the review that you received. You will not contact them at all about the review that you received. IF YOU DO:

Your communication will not stay private. It will be posted on the site for the world to see, and shared to social media. Your whinging and/or harassing will be publicly displayed, as will any follow-up whinges about it being posted publicly.

If you act like a child, you will be treated like a child.

THE DNF Policy

As of October 1st, 2016, We are instituting a policy concerning DNF reviews.

  1. We will read every book to at least the 50% mark before making the decision to DNF it. That means we’ve given the book until the halfway point to hook us. If your book hasn’t hooked us by then, the chances of it happening in the last half are slim to none.
  2. Depending on the reason for DNF, we may not review your book on Sci-Fi & Scary. (Will still post my reasons on Goodreads.) Reasons we may DNF (includes, but not all) If it’s because the book just isn’t for us. If it’s because we DNFed it quickly due to a complete lack of editing.
  3. We will not assign star ratings to your book if we DNF it.  I WILL possibly talk about the book in a review, including stating why I chose not to finish it, but we will not officially rate it anywhere (except if it’s a Netgalley book. We will rate on Netgalley.). We will not post DNF reviews to Amazon or Barnes and Noble because of the forced to rate.
  4. This does not mean you will no longer see bad reviews on Sci-Fi & Scary. Because trust me, some books we hate so much we have to finish, just so we can have a good rant about them.

To Request A Review

If you would like us to read and review your book, please complete the Review Request form on this site.

 Be Aware: After we receive your submission, if we are unsure whether to take your story for review, we may ask for a sample (generally just sending me the first chapter is fine.) This will let us know if we really are a good fit for each other. You are welcome to send a sample without prompting along with your review submission.

We have registered with The Indie View.


Our Film Review Policy

Current FILM REVIEW status:

Open to all science fiction and horror films for review.

Streaming links as well as physical copies are accepted.


We do not care about your films budget. We do not care who is in it. Independent films will be reviewed with the same attention as blockbusters are.

We do not care if your film is a new release, or has been out for a while.

If your film sucks, we won’t review it. This is not to be nice, but simply because we’re not going to sit through a 2 hour movie we can’t stand.  We will give it to the 50% mark, as in our book DNF policy. If at that point we have no desire to finish watching it, we will not.


Film reviews and/or ratings will be posted to:

  • IMBD
  • Amazon
  • Rotten Tomatoes
  • Others, if specifically requested


We feel it’s important to note, folks, that you should really take a look at our list of movie reviews before deciding whether or not to submit a film for review to this site. Both of us (Lilyn and Grace) have odd tastes in movies, with a serious love of B-roll type films. We absolutely love some films that other people can’t stand, because they’re “so bad they’re good”.  (We love regular horror and sci-fi films as well, but we’re very picky. Or not picky enough, depending upon who you ask.)

Please refer up to our public shaming part of our book review policy. It applies here. Should you choose to harass or attempt to coerce a reviewer into giving you a better review than the one that was honestly given, you will be afforded the same treatment given to the authors who act like that.

To Request A Review

If you would like us to watch and review your film, please complete the Review Request form on this site.



6 thoughts on “Review Policies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Loading Disqus Comments ...
Loading Facebook Comments ...